Showing posts with label Jack. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jack. Show all posts

Thursday, December 6, 2007

Can you get too big?

Recent "turmoil" has erupted over at wikipedia concerning secret email lists and crazy blocks and the like. I won't go into details, and I won't comment much on them either. Here are some things about wikiHow that will make it different...hopefully:

1) Sight of goals - One of the problems at WP is that it is so large that it has lost sight of its goals. wikiHow's mission is rather simple: build the world's largest how-to manual that anyone can edit. By keeping this in mind, Jack and wikiHow's leadership has helped steer potentially hazardous situations away from influencing the community. This will help it stay strong and not become overstressed from paranoia and divisive issues.

2) Leadership - wikiHow has been reluctant to set up arbitration committees and such that create an us vs. them complex. By keeping decisions within the community, everyone feels as if their voice is just as equal as someone else's. What some don't realize is how important that is to the current group of admins. Popular perception is that wikiHow admins reign on high. What is more realistic, however, is that many admins go about their normal business, and do weild crazy powers. The ultimate goal from someone shouldn't be their adminship.

3) Jack - He won't admit it, but the principle reason wikiHow is the way it is can be atributed to how Jack set up wikiHow in the first place. A lot has changed since then, and a there are many different policies now. But he has always been a steward of wikiHow and has not let "fame" and "fortune" cloud his judgement. Furthermore, by allowing wikiHow users the right to fork and his constant goal of maintaining transparency, wikiHow continues to move upward without compromising (too many) principles.

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Ultimate goal

A recent forum discussion led me to contemplate about the long-term goal of wikiHow and the purpose it serves.

Jack posted a very interesting response to the question of whether we had become the world's largest how-to manual already. His essential thoughts, summarized, indicated that we had a long way to go to become the largest.

Throughout the thread, various levels of thought came through showing what editors view as the ruler in measuring size. I even posted my own thoughts that we should be seeking to amass all of the how-to information possible in the vast reaches of human knowledge. Others compared wikiHow to all of the books ever written that speak to how to do something. Still others compared wikiHow to other how-to web sites like eHow.

Jack even went ruler-by-ruler comparing wikiHow to eHow, web site popularity and the like.

But is wikiHow the largest how-to manual on the planet? I don't think so. I think the largest how-to manual is in our collective brains. That is, human knowledge is a far larger how-to manual than wikiHow could ever be. Every day we are doing tasks that others can't perform. wikiHow itself weeds out articles about how to do something that violate its policies...but are nonetheless, a how-to.

That makes me wonder if wikiHow will ever be the world's largest how-to manual. It's certainly possible many years down the road. You might be asking, If the world's largest how-to manual is human knowledge, how will wikiHow ever pass that?! What many don't realize is that human knowledge is quickly being downloaded and dispersed throughout the world. It isn't a far reaching thought that one day we might just plug ourselves into a USB port.

Wednesday, August 8, 2007

Optimism Revisited

I recently had the pleasure of talking with Jack about his optimism and what makes him tick. First, here are some quotes:

We're doing more than just editing pages and getting in the occasional debate about new policies...we are changing the world. I really believe that. And as wikiHow grows, it will become more apparent how we are making the world a better place and influencing others. We are still several years from that...but it is happening.
I think this is rather startling! I mean, he really believes we're changing the world. But in retrospect, I can see that. I think inside all of us, we believe we're making some kind of impact on the world. And what better way to do that, than to be a part of some international wiki site that challenges all of us to do something better.

Jack goes on to say that he is refreshed every morning by wikiHow's "long term goal" and not by the daily grind. I think that's what separates visionaries from laborers. Not to say that any other editors lack vision, but I can understand how Jack truly believes that wikiHow's long term goal is the ultimate goal. And as an editor at wikiHow, I have to help get wikiHow to that goal.

Tuesday, August 7, 2007

On wikimania 2007

Just to get this out of the way, I didn't actually go to wikimania (in Taipei). It would have been great, and I've even been there before, but I could not fit it into my schedule.

In any case, Jack gave us a great report about the conference (http://www.wikihow.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5581) and many of his insights.

I'd like to pull some of them apart and talk about them.

1) Administrator selection - For any long-time wiki contributor (whether it's WP or wikiHow), you know that admin selection is a harrowing and crazy experience. Those who are selected think it's the greatest thing since toasted bread, but those who have had to vote and discuss and vote and discuss find the entire ordeal frustrating and dirty. I often feel the need to shower after a long talk.

I like Jack's presentation of the idea that we should look at the personal aspects of an individual. In admin selection, without giving too much away, we often look at the objective, calculable items. This can be the quality of edits, the quantity of edits, the way they act in forums, etc. But we never delve into the personality of the individual and inquire about their ability to mesh with the admin group and assist other users.

2) Accuracy - OMG, if you even thought about how accuracy keeps some of wikiHow's users awake at night, you would go crazy too. There have been countless discussions about how accurate an article is or isn't. It's important to consider since wikis are editable by anyone, especially on wikiHow where a non-registered user can make the same edits as a registered one. wikiHow does have a one-up on WP though. We aren't always dealing with factual data. We are dealing with real-life how-to situations. It's fairly easy to tell if a task is impossible to perform or not, whereas a fact may or may not be true depending on the source.

3) In Person - This would be so cool! I'd love to meet fellow wikiHowians out there. The consistent problem is that we all have lives outside of wikiHow that force us to choose between that which we love to do (wikiHow) and that which we have to do (school/work/studies/etc.).

I can tell that wikimania made a significant impact on Jack (and Nicole who also attended). I think that it's great that wikiHow's name is easily more recognized in the wiki-community as being a good example.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Cynical Nature

A quick review of forum posts and lively discussions throughout wikiHow shows some of us long-term folks have a certain cynical attitude to the daily goings-on. I recently came across this when I posted something rather cynical myself, on the sarcastic side.

Where does the wide-eyed optimism go? Well, to be honest, it takes a certain (rare) personality to keep that optimism going. After staying on with any project for a long duration, a normal human being eventually learns all the faults and the "dark side" of many issues. They learn to take many things comically and others too seriously. They feel that their opinion is much more valid than those wide-eyed optimists (of which they were one in the past).

What is particularly humorous about the entire situation is the fact that wikiHow's founder, Jack, is a wide-eyed optimist -- and he's proud of it. Or at least those around him are proud of it. I think it's the optimism that prevents long-term projects from failing completely. I often wonder how Jack gets out of bed in the morning. Does he think, another day another wikiHow issue, or does he come at it refreshed anew? To my amazement, I think he comes at it refreshed. His demeanor has always been positive, even when he has been weighed down with demands. It's not easy being Jack...

For that matter, it's not easy being human either...